Refrigerator Water Filter vs Under Sink Filter
A refrigerator filter treats water at the dispenser, while an under sink filter treats water at the faucet. This guide compares the two setups using listing facts so you can match the right part to your kitchen.
Part of our guide: Choosing and matching a filter
The choice between a refrigerator water filter and an under sink filter comes down to where you want filtered water: at the fridge dispenser or at the kitchen faucet. A refrigerator filter is a cartridge that fits a specific fridge model, while an under sink system is a separate housing and cartridge installed on the cold water line. Some products, like the Culligan RC-EZ-4, are listed for both under sink and refrigerator systems, so the lines are not always strict.
- 1Part on your old filterSamsung DA29-00020BPrinted on the cartridge label
- 2Same part asHAF-CIN/EXPAlso sold as DA29-00020B; DA29-00020A
- 3ReplaceEvery 6 months or 300 gallonsSooner if flow slows or taste changes
- 4Before you orderMatch the part numberOn the box or listing: HAF-CIN/EXP
Before you pick either path, check your refrigerator model number and the part number printed on the current cartridge or in the manual. Then confirm what the listing says about fit, certifications, and replacement interval. The products below show how those details appear in real listings.
Filters we compared
Waterdrop WD-10UA Under Sink Water Filter
The Waterdrop WD-10UA is a compact under-sink filtration system built for municipal tap water, using a coconut-shell carbon block to reduce chlorine, lead, and PFOA/PFOS while keeping beneficial minerals. Its twist-and-lock design and push-to-connect fittings are rated for a three-minute install and three-second filter changes, and the 3/8-inch outlet supports a fast flow rate for daily drinking and cooking. It suits renters and homeowners who want straightforward under-counter filtration without a permanent plumbing overhaul.
Reasons to buy
- NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI/CAN 372 certified for the stated contaminant reduction and material safety
- Tool-free twist-and-lock filter changes and push-to-connect fittings simplify installation
- Upgraded filtration area provides a 20X increase in dirt adhesion area to reduce clogging risk
- Compatible with UF and MZ filter upgrades, and replacement filters are budget-friendly
- Compact 3.9 by 3.6 by 12.3 inch footprint fits kitchens, bathrooms, RVs, and offices
Reasons to avoid
- Designed only for cold municipal water, not suitable for well water or hot water sources
- TDS meters will not show a drop because the system intentionally retains dissolved minerals
- Requires a female-threaded faucet connection in 1/2 inch or 3/8 inch, so buyers should confirm compatibility before purchase
Culligan RC-EZ-4 Under-Sink Replacement Filter
A drop-in replacement cartridge for Culligan's US-EZ series under-sink systems, rated to reduce lead, cysts, VOCs, and chloramines at 0.5 microns. The twist-off design shuts off water automatically during changes, so no buckets or wrenches are needed. The listing states a certification (not yet checked by us).
Reasons to buy
- The listing states NSF/ANSI 42 and 53 (IAPMO) (not yet checked by us).
- 0.5 micron activated carbon block targets fine sediment and cysts like Cryptosporidium and Giardia
- Twist-off cartridge change shuts water off automatically, avoiding the mess of traditional swaps
- Up to 500 gallons or 6 months of filter life, with a 2-year limited warranty
- Compatible with Culligan US-EZ-1, US-EZ-3, and US-EZ-4 under-sink systems
Reasons to avoid
- Only fits Culligan EZ-Change under-sink systems, not other brands or standard housings
- Maximum flow rate of 0.5 gpm may feel slow for filling large containers
Frizzlife MS99 Inline Water Filter System
The Frizzlife MS99 is a compact inline filtration system that connects to a refrigerator, ice maker, or under-sink faucet. It is certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and 53 for reducing lead, chlorine, and particulates, and its twist-in cartridge design allows filter changes without shutting off the water supply. With a 2-year filter life and support for both PEX and copper tubing, it suits renters and homeowners who want cleaner water without a dedicated filtration faucet.
Reasons to buy
- Certified by IAPMO R&T against NSF/ANSI 42 and 53 for lead, chlorine, taste, odor, and particulate reduction
- Long 2-year filter life and 1,600-gallon capacity help lower replacement costs
- Twist-in cartridge and auto shut-off design make filter changes quick and mess-free
- Flexible installation with included PEX tubing and a filter head that accepts copper tubing
- Fast flow rate of up to 1.4 gpm, filling a 330ml cup in about 3 seconds
Reasons to avoid
- Requires 6 inches of clearance if mounted behind a refrigerator, which may limit placement in tight spaces
- Only the inner cartridge is replaceable, so the housing must be kept and reused
How to Choose Refrigerator Water Filter vs Under Sink Filter
Match the part number and model names in the listing
The Culligan listing names the RC-EZ-4 cartridge and says it fits Culligan US-EZ-1, US-EZ-3, and US-EZ-4 under sink systems. The Frizzlife listing names the MS99 system and says it works with non-filter refrigerators, under sink faucets, coffee makers, ice makers, and water dispensers. The Waterdrop listing names the 10UA system and the WD-RF10 replacement filter, and it says the system is for municipal tap water and cold water sources only.
Compare what the listings say about certifications
The Culligan listing states IAPMO certification to NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine taste and odor, chloramines, and particulate Class 1, and to NSF/ANSI 53 for lead, cysts, mercury, VOC, MTBE, and turbidity. The Frizzlife listing states the full system is certified by IAPMO R&T against NSF/ANSI 42 and 53 and that it reduces lead, chlorine, taste and odor, and particulates. The Waterdrop listing states NSF/ANSI 42 certification. Always read the current listing and the manual for the exact claims that apply to your setup.
Check the replacement interval each listing gives
The Culligan listing says the cartridge lasts up to 500 gallons or 6 months depending on usage and water conditions. The Frizzlife listing says each MS99 cartridge delivers up to 2 years of filtration and that only the inner core needs replacement. The Waterdrop listing says each system has a maximum service life of 12 months with municipal water and that replacement filters are available separately. These intervals are listing statements, so confirm them against your own water use and the manual.
Look at pack size and what is included
The Culligan listing describes a single replacement cartridge for EZ-Change systems. The Frizzlife listing describes a full inline system with compression brass fittings, PEX tubing, and a wrench included for filter changes. The Waterdrop listing describes a full under sink system with push-to-connect fittings and a 3/8 inch line, and it notes a separate replacement filter part number. Check whether you are buying a cartridge only or a complete system before you order.
Confirm what each product says it fits
The Culligan listing ties the cartridge to specific Culligan under sink systems, so it is not a universal fridge cartridge. The Frizzlife listing says it fits non-filter refrigerators and most standard 3/8 inch US water supplies, and it asks you to reserve 6 inches of clearance if mounting behind the refrigerator. The Waterdrop listing says it connects to 1/2 inch and 3/8 inch cold water pipes and faucets with a converter fitting, and it is not for well water or hot water. Where the data is silent on your exact model, check the listing and the refrigerator manual.
Check Before You Buy
Find the refrigerator model number on a label inside the fresh food compartment or on the back of the unit, and write it down exactly. Then compare that model number with the part number on your current filter or in the manual. Our guide to finding your refrigerator model number walks through the label locations. You can also use the filter finder to narrow down the part number before you order.
- 1Part on your old filterWhirlpool EDR1RXD1Printed on the cartridge label
- 2Also sold asW10295370A; everydrop Filter 1Same filter, other part numbers or pack sizes
- 3ReplaceEvery 6 monthsSooner if flow slows or taste changes
- 4Before you orderMatch the part numberOn the box or listing: EDR1RXD1 (Filter 1)
FAQ
Can I use an under sink filter instead of a refrigerator filter?
An under sink filter treats water at the faucet, not at the fridge dispenser, so it does not replace a fridge cartridge for dispenser water. The Frizzlife listing says its MS99 works with non-filter refrigerators and can be installed on the refrigerator angle valve, which is a different setup from a built-in cartridge. Check your manual to see what your refrigerator requires.
Does the Culligan RC-EZ-4 fit my refrigerator?
The Culligan listing says the RC-EZ-4 fits Culligan US-EZ-1, US-EZ-3, and US-EZ-4 under sink systems and is also listed for refrigerator and RV systems. It does not name specific refrigerator models, so check the listing and your refrigerator manual before buying.
How often do these filters need replacing?
The Culligan listing says up to 500 gallons or 6 months, the Frizzlife listing says up to 2 years per cartridge, and the Waterdrop listing says a maximum of 12 months with municipal water. These are listing statements, so follow the interval in your own manual and adjust for your water conditions.
What certifications should I look for in the listing?
The listings here mention NSF/ANSI 42 and NSF/ANSI 53, with Culligan and Frizzlife stating IAPMO certification and Waterdrop stating NSF/ANSI 42. Read the current listing for the exact claims and check the manual for what your refrigerator or system requires.
Can I install an under sink filter myself?
The Frizzlife listing says everything needed is in the package and the system can be installed in a few minutes without extra tools. The Waterdrop listing describes push-to-connect fittings and a three-minute installation. If you are unsure about your plumbing, check the manual or ask a qualified installer.
This article was written by the MatchMyFilter editorial team from manufacturer and listing information. We do not run lab tests. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
More on this topic: How to Choose and Match a Refrigerator Water Filter
Related guides
Browse all refrigerator water filter guides
